josecustom.ai josecustom.ai Book

Got an ADA Website Demand Letter? What to Do First

What an ADA website demand letter is, the steps to take in the first two weeks, how to check whether its claims hold up, what you can actually be made to pay, and how your state changes the picture.

An ADA website demand letter is a letter from a law firm claiming that your website cannot be used by people with disabilities, usually someone using a screen reader, and asking you to fix it and pay a settlement. It is not a lawsuit and it is not a court order. It is an offer to resolve a claim before one gets filed. You should not ignore it, and you should not pay it on the first day either.

The first two weeks are what matter. Here is the order I would do things in, written from the side I know: the website. I am a security engineer who builds websites, not a lawyer, so this post covers how to prepare and what to check. The legal response itself belongs to an attorney with ADA Title III experience.

What should you do first?

1. Write down the deadline and do not reply yet. Most letters set a response date. Note it, and do not call or email the sender to explain your side. What you say can be used later, and an informal apology can read like an admission.

2. Confirm the sender is real. Look up the attorney in the state bar directory for the state where they claim to practice. Search the firm and the named plaintiff on CourtListener or PACER, which will show whether they have filed similar cases. Be especially careful with anything asking for payment by wire, gift card, or a link in the letter.

3. Check whether anything has actually been filed. A letter has a deadline set by the sender. A served summons and complaint has one set by the court, and in federal court it is generally 21 days. If you were served, call a lawyer today.

4. Keep the records. Once a dispute is reasonably foreseeable, you can have a legal duty to preserve relevant evidence. Save the letter, the envelope or email it came in, and any complaints from site visitors. Do not delete pages, analytics, or correspondence to clean things up.

5. Capture the site as it is today. Before you change anything, save copies of the pages named in the letter, including full-page screenshots and a backup from your website platform. If your web developer has a change log, ask them to keep it. You want to be able to show what the site looked like before and after.

6. Tell your insurance broker. Ask whether any policy covers this claim, and report it either way. Coverage for website accessibility claims varies and is often excluded, but policies have notice requirements, and reporting late can cost you coverage you did have.

7. Talk to an ADA Title III attorney before the deadline. General business counsel may be fine for reviewing the settlement paperwork, but this is a repetitive specialty, so someone who handles these letters regularly will know the firm that sent yours and how it tends to behave. Ask what a response would involve and what it would cost before you hire them.

How do you check whether the letter is right?

Letters like this are often built from automated scans, so run the same kind of scan yourself. It takes about an hour.

  1. Test the exact pages the letter names with WAVE and the Lighthouse accessibility audit in Chrome.
  2. Do the keyboard test. Put the mouse away and try to use your menu, contact form, and checkout or booking flow using only Tab, Shift+Tab, Enter, and the arrow keys.
  3. Try the specific failures listed. If the letter says a product page has unlabeled images, turn on your computer’s built-in screen reader (VoiceOver on a Mac, Narrator on Windows) and listen to that page.
  4. Compare the dates and pages. Does the letter describe the site you actually have, or pages you removed years ago? Note the differences for your lawyer.

Make a plain list: what the letter claims, what you found, and whether it is true. A letter can have the wrong details and still be right about your site, so errors in it do not mean you can relax. Automated tools also miss problems, so a clean scan does not prove the site is accessible. I covered the standard and the most common failures in ADA website compliance for small businesses.

Should you fix the site right away?

Generally, yes, after you have captured its current state and let your lawyer weigh in on how to document the work. Your attorney may want an outside accessibility audit commissioned through their office, so ask first if the letter is serious.

Fixing the site does three useful things. It shrinks your exposure to the next letter, because a settlement with one plaintiff typically does nothing to stop another. It gives your lawyer something concrete to point to in negotiations. And it may help in court: some federal judges have dismissed website cases as moot when the evidence showed the site had been made accessible and the plaintiff did not rebut it. Seyfarth Shaw, a law firm that tracks these cases, reported one such dismissal in 2026. That result is not guaranteed, and it does not end claims for money under state laws that allow them.

One thing not to do is buy a widget and call it fixed. In 2025 the Federal Trade Commission finalized a $1 million order against accessiBe over claims that its automated tool could make any website compliant with WCAG. A vendor that contacts you right after a letter with a one-line fix deserves extra skepticism. The repair happens in the site itself: the labels, headings, contrast, keyboard behavior, and any third-party booking or payment tools you have embedded.

What can you actually be made to pay?

This is the part the letter tends to leave vague, and it depends on which law the claim relies on.

Under federal ADA Title III, a private plaintiff cannot win money damages. The available remedies are a court order to make the site accessible, plus attorney’s fees and costs if the plaintiff prevails. The money pressure comes from those fees and from what it costs you to defend the case, which is why settling is so common even without a damages claim.

State law can add damages. California is the clearest example. Its Unruh Civil Rights Act (Civil Code section 52) sets a minimum of $4,000 per violation, so a California plaintiff can seek money directly. Courts have disagreed about how violations are counted for websites, and whether a website with no physical location is covered at all raises its own questions. Other states have their own disability access laws, so ask your lawyer which apply to you.

Settlement figures in these letters are opening numbers, and there is no public rate card. A lawyer who sees these letters regularly can tell you what a reasonable outcome looks like. Before signing anything, ask three questions:

  • Who does the release cover, and who can still bring a claim afterward?
  • What does the agreement require you to fix, by what standard, and by when?
  • What happens if a later scan finds something you missed?

Does your state change anything?

Yes. It changes where you can be sued, what the plaintiff can recover, and how settled the law is. Plaintiffs filed 5,006 ADA Title III lawsuits of all kinds in federal court in the first half of 2026, according to Seyfarth Shaw’s mid-year report. California led with 2,426, then Florida with 709, Illinois with 505, and New York with 485. Those numbers cover physical locations too. Seyfarth counted 3,117 federal website cases for all of 2025, up 27% from 2024.

New York. Seyfarth attributes New York’s lower federal count to stricter standing rules in its federal courts, which push plaintiffs to file in state court instead. Lower federal numbers there do not mean less activity.

Florida, Georgia, and Alabama. These states sit in the Eleventh Circuit, which held in Gil v. Winn-Dixie in 2021 that websites are not themselves places of public accommodation under Title III. That opinion was later vacated as moot, so it does not bind courts there. I would not assume you are safe in these states because of it.

Everywhere else. Courts still differ on whether a website needs a connection to a physical location to be covered. That argument is one for your lawyer to weigh. It should not be your reason for leaving the site unfixed.

What should you keep after this is over?

Once the letter is resolved, a few small habits keep you out of the same position.

  • Retest when the site changes. New pages, new themes, and new plugins are where accessibility breaks. Add a WAVE scan and keyboard test to whatever website maintenance routine you already have.
  • Check third-party tools. Booking widgets, chat tools, and payment forms sit on your pages. Ask those vendors about accessibility and test them yourself.
  • Publish a way to ask for help. An accessibility page with a real phone number and email gives someone who hits a problem a way to reach you. It will not prevent a lawsuit, but you may learn about a problem from a customer before you hear about it from a lawyer.
  • Keep a dated record. Save scan results and notes on what you fixed.
  • Ask your tax preparer about the Disabled Access Credit. Businesses that qualify can claim a credit of 50% of eligible accessibility spending between $250 and $10,250 a year (IRS Form 8826). Ask whether your remediation counts.

Frequently asked questions

Is an ADA website demand letter a lawsuit?

No. A demand letter is a private request from a law firm to fix the site and usually pay a settlement, and the deadline is set by the sender. A lawsuit starts when a complaint is filed in court and you are served with it, and the response deadline is then set by court rules. Ignoring a letter can lead to a lawsuit, so get legal advice before its deadline.

Can I ignore an ADA demand letter?

You should not. Ignoring it gives up your chance to resolve the claim before it is filed, and a lawsuit usually costs more to deal with. Verify the sender, preserve your records, and talk to an attorney before the deadline, even if the letter looks like a form letter.

Can a small business be sued for website accessibility in Georgia or Florida?

Yes. Federal website accessibility lawsuits are filed against businesses in both states, and Florida is one of the busiest states for ADA Title III cases. The Eleventh Circuit’s 2021 opinion in Gil v. Winn-Dixie favored the business, but it was vacated as moot, so it does not settle the question for courts in those states.

Does fixing my website make the demand letter go away?

Not automatically. Fixing the site reduces your exposure to future claims and can support your position, but the sender may still pursue attorney’s fees, or damages where state law allows them. Some federal courts have dismissed cases as moot once a site was shown to be accessible, but results vary by court and by the evidence.

Do I need a lawyer to respond to an ADA demand letter?

It is strongly advisable. The technical side, including scanning and fixing the site, is something you or your web developer can handle. Deciding how to respond, whether to settle, and what to sign are legal questions, and the release terms in a settlement matter as much as the dollar figure.

The one-sentence version

Note the deadline, verify the sender, save everything, capture the site as it is, tell your insurance broker, talk to an ADA Title III attorney, and fix the real failures in the site itself rather than installing a widget.

If your site needs that repair work, or the honest answer is that it needs replacing, I build small business websites to WCAG 2.1 AA from the start, and the pricing is published on the page.


Jose Lugo is a CISSP-certified security engineer with 12 years of U.S. Army intelligence experience. He builds secure AI work environments and fast, maintainable websites for businesses at josecustom.ai. This post is general information, not legal advice. See his portfolio of 13 live client systems at portfolio.josecustom.ai.